Is a dollar in a 401(k) worth a dollar in cash?
No. A traditional 401(k) is taxed when the money comes out, so $100,000 there buys less than $100,000 in savings or a Roth. An even split on paper can leave one person with much less after tax.
Updated October 5, 2026 · 6 minute read
Same balance, different spendable amount
Accounts are usually compared by the balance on the statement. You spend money after taxes, though, and different kinds of accounts are taxed differently when the money comes out. Here is $100,000 in four kinds of account. These are made-up round numbers, and the tax rates are assumptions chosen to show the arithmetic. Your real rates depend on your income, your state and when you take the money out.
| Account | What is taxed when you take it out | About what you could spend |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional 401(k) or IRA (pre-tax) | The whole amount, as income, at an assumed 25% | $75,000 |
| Roth IRA or Roth 401(k) | Nothing, if the withdrawal meets the IRS rules for a qualified distribution | $100,000 |
| Savings or checking | Nothing; the interest was taxed as it was earned | $100,000 |
| Brokerage account that cost $70,000 | The $30,000 gain, at an assumed 15% | $95,500 |
Money taken from a traditional 401(k) or IRA is taxed as ordinary income. Qualified distributions from a Roth are tax-free; the IRS's Publication 590-B has the exact rules. Gains on investments held more than a year are taxed at 0%, 15% or 20% for most people, depending on taxable income and filing status, while shorter-term gains are taxed as ordinary income.
Why it matters when one is traded for another
Say the person keeping the house owes a $90,000 buyout and offers part of their 401(k) to cover it. At the assumed 25% rate, $90,000 in a pre-tax account is worth $67,500 to spend. To hand over $90,000 of spendable value from that account, it takes $120,000 in the account. Cash and Roth dollars don't need that adjustment.
Whether to trade accounts at face value, to adjust for tax, or to do something else is for the two of you and your attorney or mediator to settle. This guide only shows why the question is worth asking. The house buyout guide shows how a buyout number is worked out in the first place.
How retirement accounts are divided
- Employer plans (a 401(k), a 403(b) or a pension) are divided with a qualified domestic relations order, called a QDRO: a court order that the plan's administrator reviews and approves. It is an extra step with its own paperwork and cost, separate from the divorce decree itself. The US Department of Labor has a plain-language guide to QDROs (PDF).
- IRAs are divided a different way and don't need a QDRO. A transfer of an IRA to a spouse or former spouse that is made as part of a divorce is treated as a transfer, not as a taxable withdrawal. (IRS Publication 504)
The 10% early-withdrawal tax
Taking money out of a retirement plan or IRA before age 59½ generally adds a 10% additional tax on top of income tax, unless an exception applies. One exception is for money paid to a former spouse under a QDRO from an employer plan. The IRS lists it in its exceptions to the tax on early distributions and marks it as not applying to IRAs.
In the example, if a former spouse took $50,000 from a 401(k) under a QDRO at age 45, the additional 10% ($5,000) would not apply. The $50,000 would still count as income unless it is rolled over into a retirement account of their own. A tax professional can say what that means for a particular year.
Questions to ask before agreeing
- Which accounts are pre-tax, Roth or taxable, and what is each worth after tax?
- Does the agreement trade accounts of different kinds at face value?
- Is a QDRO needed, who prepares it, and who pays for it?
- Is there a pension, and does the agreement say what happens to survivor benefits?
- Has a tax professional looked at the withdrawals, and when they would be taken?
See it with your own numbers
The free house calculator works out a buyout from your figures. The full version adds a settlement-package tool that compares ways of dividing everything by what each would leave you after taxes and selling costs, using rates you set yourself. Nothing you type leaves your device.
Not legal or tax advice
This guide explains how the numbers work. It doesn't say what you're entitled to, what a court or mediator will decide, or how the tax rules apply to you. That depends on your state and your situation, and an attorney, mediator or tax professional licensed where you live can answer it. Tax rules and rates change, so check current figures before you rely on them.